Thats right.. step right on up Californians.. the more YOU LOSE, the more money the State will have to spend! What a deal! Let's all go get big L's tatooed in the middle of our foreheads after forking over our money to the sacred slot machine to show 'we care'. From the Morgan Hill Times:
Filling a slot
The current presidential campaigns, which have now gone on longer than FDR's presidency and spent a sum of money nearly equal to the gross national product of Mitt Romney, have mutually decided that there is a single word which defines, delineates, describes, and distills what America wants, needs, and hopes for in the next administration. That word is change. No, make that Change; wait, I've got it: CHANGE. No, I mean CHANGE!!!. No, hold on -- imagine an enormous billboard, say, the size of western Nebraska, floating overhead and imagine the word CHANGE completely filling it, in flashing neon with Roman candles going off and cannons firing, and the special effects guys from "Lord of the Rings" making it do all kinds of really interesting things, and ... .
Anyway, we need change; we get it. And in California, thanks to the small piece of this miserable circus which actually wended its annoying over-commercialized way to a conclusion on Stupor Tuesday, we, alone among our sister states, have officially declared that we really need change, need it bad, need it now.
We need change, preferably quarters, to funnel into the shiny, flashy, electronic noise-making new slot machines, all 17,000 of them, which we approved by a large margin after discovering that slot machines have recently become a threatened species due to excessive expansion of non-gambling activities in this state, requiring that drastic steps be taken to preserve and protect our precious casino environment before it's too late. If through our own negligent selfishness we fail to grow our native slot machine population so that our descendants can enjoy the awesome beauty of thundering herds of one-armed bandits roaming free across the Southern California plains grazing on our money we will have deprived posterity of a sacred right.
Naw! I was just joshing with you; we didn't do it for the environment, we did it for the money! Yes, we decided to partner up with the tribes to "share the revenues" and help bail out the State after discovering that pesky $14 billion shortfall. Perfect: just as the public is hit with the body-blow of a huge budget crisis the tribes come along and generously offer to help -- a win-win outcome if ever there was one, so of course everybody says look, free money and just when we need it. And now we all have a vested interest in the success of those bigger and better casinos, because the more they make the more they share and the more we get the better off we are.
There is a small fly in the ointment, really nothing worth bothering about: revenue sharing comes from profits and profits come from gamblers who lose. That's how it works -- players lose, house wins, house gives some to us. The more of the first the more of the second and the more of the third. So the logic of the situation takes us far beyond legalizing gambling and far beyond tolerating gambling; it is now officially in our interest to ENCOURAGE gambling, or more specifically, to encourage losing. We have to want our fellow Californians (who are the majority of the gamblers in Indian casinos) to get in there and lose, lose big, lose often. If we don't have a large continuous stream of players pouring coins, bills, and credit cards into those machines without equal reward there won't be much profit, and we will be getting chump-change out of the deal. All those millions that the tribes could afford to spend on advertising, all the sympathy generated for their earnest desire to become self-reliant so they could share the wealth with us, will produce only a drop in the deficit bucket.
So come on, people! Step up to the plate and show us what you're made of; put your money where your vote was. We don't want to pay several dollars more in taxes, do we? Of course not; root canals without anaesthetic are infinitely better than paying any amount at all in increased taxes no matter what they're used for. So it's up to us to make the alternative work; we have to go to the Indian casino of our choice and lose hundreds, thousands if possible. We need to be making bad bets, reckless wagers; don't quit just because you're behind.
This will be good, really. It's not a bad thing, it's totally different. See, the problem with traditional gambling is that traditional gamblers are pitiful creatures, blowing the rent money on their favorite roulette number, staking the kids' college fund on long odds, and getting deeper and deeper in the hole because they always think the next bet is going to turn it all around; they're going to become winners raking in the chips and overtipping the croupier like in the movies. But we're just the opposite: we WANT to lose -- winning is not an option. If we go into a casino and don't come out broke we've failed California: we've failed our kids' schools, we've failed our highways and bridges, we've failed our cops and firefighters. Every dollar we don't put in a slot machine means revenue the casinos can't share with the State. Can't have that; defeats the whole purpose of the election.
So, in keeping with the version of reality California has always been most fond of, the only way to win is to lose. If we all do our part someday the Governor will call a press conference, smile that inimitable Schwarzenegger smile, and proudly announce that our budget woes are over because we have met the challenge: we are all losers.
Friday, February 15, 2008
Hey California!! Change! We needed it! We got it! .. uh.. whoops?
Posted by
sosumi
at
5:23 PM|PERMALINK
1 comments
Labels: indian casino, Schwarzenegger, slot machines
Monday, February 11, 2008
Poor Oklahoma indians may have to pay millions to fund education
Sounds like they're on to something. Most would agree that casino indian tribes are not paying fairly into our tax system. The article was interesting enough, but then I got to the comments. Take a peek for yourself. Apparently one person felt that our government is not giving to the tribes and only takes, takes, takes. Last time I checked, the government IS still giving indians millions in aid. So our government is taking our tax money and turning around to give it back to the indian people...poor indians? - don't think so.
Proposed gaming restrictions could hurt tribes
By Associated Press
OKLAHOMA CITY -- A proposed new federal restriction on the types of slot machines tribes can offer at casinos could cost Oklahoma tribes millions of dollars each year, but would boost funding for the state's education system.
The National Indian Gaming Commission wants to create a greater distinction between Class II games based on bingo and Class III, or Las Vegas-style, slot machines.
The distinction is important because states can only collect a portion of tribes' profits from Class III games.
Indian gaming experts have said the vast majority of existing Class II machines would become illegal in 2013 if the new regulations, as proposed, take effect.
Tribes have almost universally denounced the plan as an unfair imposition on their sovereignty.
Two Oklahoma congressmen seem to agree, according to their recent letters to the commission.
"I remain deeply concerned that there has not been sufficient consideration of the economic impacts of these proposed regulations," Rep. Dan Boren, D-Okla., wrote in a Dec. 20 letter.
Boren joined Rep. Tom Cole, R-Okla., in a second letter asking that the comment period on the proposed changes be extended
until June.
However, a letter signed by 10 other congressmen urges "prompt adoption" of the proposed rules.
Both Boren and Cole are on the House Natural Resources Committee, which oversees Indian gaming.
The 30,044 Class II machines in Oklahoma at the end of 2006 represented 59 percent of all such machines in the country, economist Alan Meister reported in a study prepared for the Indian gaming commission.
In 2004, Oklahoma voters approved compacts allowing tribes to offer modified Class III slot machines. In return, tribes must pay the state 4 percent to 6 percent of the revenue.
That money goes to fund teacher pay raises and other education programs. Tribes paid the state $54.5 million from Class III machine revenue in 2007, according to the Office of State Finance.
Most state tribal casinos have incorporated Class III games, and a few have moved solely to compacted machines. However, Class II machines still comprise a large majority of the games available in Oklahoma, Meister reported.
Meister said the proposed Class II restrictions would force tribes to use only compacted machines by 2013.
If that happens, Oklahoma tribes would have to pay the state an estimated $122.3 million a year in revenue-sharing costs, Meister reported.
Oklahoma's current tribal gaming compacts expire in 2020.
Posted by
Anonymous
at
12:24 PM|PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: gaming restrictions, Oklahoma tribe, slot machines, sovereignty
Indian casino cheats patron with their sovereign immunity
Once again we have a tribe playing their sovereign immunity card, kind of like a "get out of jail free" card in Monopoly. Only Monopoly is a level playing field where everyone has to play by the same rules. Casino tribes don't play by the same rules governing the rest of us. They get to ignore planning departments, OSHA regulations, fair labor practices, taxes, environmental laws AND still get free health benefits paid by you and me while individually making monthly incomes of ten, twenty, forty thousand dollars a month or more depending on the tribe.
Judge dismisses jackpot lawsuit against Sandia casino
The Associated Press
Article Launched: 02/04/2008 05:09:19 PM MST
ALBUQUERQUE—A state district judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by a Bernalillo County man who accused Sandia Resort & Casino of not paying him a jackpot of nearly $1.6 million.
Gary Hoffman claimed he was playing a slot machine in August 2006 when hit the jackpot. The casino refused to pay, saying the machine wasn't working properly and that Hoffman had actually won about $400.
Hoffman alleged the casino violated the Unfair Trade Practices Act and he sued for the jackpot winnings plus punitive damages.
Paul Bardacke, an attorney representing Sandia Pueblo, argued that the tribe couldn't be sued in state district court because of sovereign immunity, and Judge Linda Vanzi agreed during a hearing Monday.
Hoffman's attorney, Sam Bregman, said he will appeal the ruling.
Bregman argued that tribal sovereignty wasn't meant to protect tribes from luring people to their casinos and then cheating them out of their winnings.
"This decision has national implications," he said. "There are billions of dollars at stake when it comes to Indian gaming and the idea that they never have to be held accountable is very troubling."
previously on TribalWatch:
Ripped off on the Reservation
Posted by
sosumi
at
9:48 AM|PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: indian casino, lawsuit, Sandia, slot machines, sovereing immunity
Tuesday, February 5, 2008
Before you head to the polls...
... you might want to read this if you still have any confusion regarding 94, 95, 96 and 97. One of our regular readers sent this out to family members forwarded a copy to me. I thought it would be a good post for today, election day.
Dear friends and family,
Why we should vote note on 94 - 97.
At stake there is a supposed 9 Billion dollars of revenue for the State of California, and for the tribes almost 20,000 slot machines. California will far surpass Nevada as a gambling State with the addition of these slots.
It is 9 billion over 20 years, around 200 million per year. It is less then .5 percent of the estimated revenue from these tribes - a FRACTION of a percent of what they would have to pay if they were any other business. Businesses and individuals pay taxes in our country to support all the infrastructure we have and need. (emergency services, roads etc. Imagine what would happen if we suddenly had no money for these things. Imagine what happens just when one business increases traffic and visits to its facility by over a million people a year, with ZERO money going to the government to cover costs related to all those new visitors, not to mention regular employees and contractors.)
Will it it actually be 9 billion? Most economists who have been crunching the numbers agree that it could be as little as half that amount. The sad fact is Indian casinos are unregulated. There is no one checking to see if they had the revenue they claim. They can and do say anything they want under the protection of their 'sovereign immunity'. They can actually decide not to pay and the state has no recourse. Once the slots are in they are in. Right now there have been lawsuits filed because they have not paid on the old compacts. Matter of fact the tribes have paid LESS THAN 10 PERCENT on the old compacts, so why should we think they will pay more on a new agreement? These lawsuits will likely be thrown out because you cannot sue a sovereign nation. So the answer is NO the state will probably not collect what is being promised and there is no recourse to do so.
Where does the 9 billion really come from? California gamblers will have to LOSE 60 BILLION dollars in the slot machines first. This is 60 billion that will not pay mortgages, utility bills, tuition or get donated to charities. It is 60 billion that will not pay for other entertainment venues where taxes to the state are generated. It is 60 billion dollars down the toilet, there are no residual taxes that will help the State. Add to that for every dollar of revenue a casino makes - there is $3 - $5 dollars in social costs (addiction and crime etc). You don't have to be a math genius to see where this is going. If you don't believe that crime and casinos go hand in hand, take a little trip to your nearest Indian casino and talk to some of the business owners and residents in the area. By the way, thats 60 billion lost in slots only. This does not include millions spent on rooms, meals and merchandise. Rooms, meals and merchandise they will charge YOU state tax on but THEY will NOT remit to the state. Illegal you say? For any other business yes but Indian casinos are immune.
Another nifty little deal that was written into these compacts was to do away with what is called the 'special distribution fund'. This fund is currently what the Indian casinos pay into and from there the money is supposed to be earmarked for certain things like helping non-casino Indian tribes, education etc. Lets forget for a moment that there are lawsuits pending because money has not been paid into the special fund properly at this time. What the governor has now arranged is for the money to go into the general fund. Where it can be used for anything, anything at all. Things like special interest projects for taking care of high-paying donors to political campaigns. So you can kiss that money good bye.
Then there are the politics behind these referendums - and this is where it gets very murky and the implications are very disturbing. This summer our Governor in a bid to secure these deals NO MATTER WHAT THE CALIFORNIA VOTERS DECIDE, sent them off for approval to the FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. See, by getting federal government approval it is thought that it will trump any vote by Californians. Tribes are under federal jurisdiction NOT the State. It gets more twisted. The Department of Interior LOST this paperwork for over 80 days. They are given 45 days to review and approve, otherwise by default, the agreements are AUTOMATICALLY APPROVED. So these compacts were approved by default without review by the feds. If you think I am nuts, just google it, it was all over the web and news 2 weeks ago. (or go to the website at the bottom of the page - it has links to original news stories)
There is much, much more. The Pechanga tribe has been taken over by outsiders and the real Pechangas have been ousted. The San Bernardino tribe is being run by the Mexican Mafia. Workers at these casinos are not protected like workers in any other business in the US, nor are visitors to Indian Casinos. The laws of the United States are not valid on tribal lands. But what you are seeing on TV is an ad blitz funded by $120,000 million dollars of gambling money telling you things that are simply not true. There is no money earmarked for education or to help poorer needier tribes, there is no guarantee the funds will be paid at all, there are no economic studies that support any of the claims the tribes are making. They are NOT creating NEW revenue - it is simply money that is going from one venue to another, and this new venue is a black hole that generates no tax money for the state. The iffy 9 billion is a mere drop in the bucket of what that money would do if it were spent elsewhere.
The tribes will say anything at all to get these slots. Not a word of it has to be true. Who is going to sue them if it isn't true? What court will allow a suit against a sovereign nation? No one and none. There are many tribes who are not included in these compacts who are against them, but they cannot afford to fight the kind of money that is being dumped into the campaign. Indeed there are tribal members within these four that are against the compacts but they cannot speak up for fear of being disenrolled.
Indian casinos for better or worse might be here to stay, but Californians could do a lot better than this measly deal by our Governor and members of the Legislature. Vote NO on 94, 95, 96 and 97.
Posted by
sosumi
at
9:34 AM|PERMALINK
4
comments
Labels: gambling, indian casino, Propositions 94 95 96 and 97, slot machines
Sunday, January 27, 2008
A marriage made in hell
Rob Walter summarizes the issues on props 94-97 quite clearly. Our 'popular' governor has decided to consummate the states' marriage to various Indian casinos by allowing them almost 20,000 more slots. Slots that take money from the population who would have otherwise spent it on things less harmful than gambling. As Mr. Walter shows below- Californians must LOSE 60 BILLION at those very slot machines to get a measly 9 billion back. The rest? Down the toilet. Add 25-40 billion in social costs directly related to gambling and you have the perfect recipe for financial disaster for the state. From The SYV Journal:
CALIFORNIA & GAMBLING
By Rob Walter, Contributing Writer
Calif. sells soul to gambling
In 1820, Congress passed the Missouri Compromise. In an agreement between pro-slavery and anti-slavery states, Missouri would be admitted to the Union as a slave state in return for designating other territories of the U.S. to be off limits to slavery. The convoluted thinking was that by agreeing to the limited expansion of the evil of slavery, we would be able to control the evil of slavery. And, by the way, the addition of Missouri to the Union would be beneficial to our national economy.
Now our Governor, who tries desperately to be well liked above all else, along with our Assembly and Senate, who try desperately to be reĆ«lected above all else, have determined that we have been engaged to the gambling interests long enough. It’s time to get married. With an “it’s the economy stupid” mentality, the California Compromise is considered a way by which with the spread of an evil, we could gain control of the evil and, more importantly, benefit the state economy. The sad fact is that they don’t see the evil for what it is.
California has a $100 billion budget. Propositions 94-97 will create the biggest casinos in the U.S. For this payoff to the gambling lobbyists and tribes, the State will receive an estimated $200 million a year extra, only 0.2 percent of our budget, allegedly growing to a projected total revenue for the state of $9 billion over the 23-year life of the tribal compacts. But now it’s official. California will have gone into the gambling business, as our Governor has become a co-conspirator with the gambling industry to fleece the public.
Now, you would think that some groups would oppose this 17,000 slot machine expansion, and they do. Reading the State Voter Guide, you will find that the unions don’t feel adequately protected or represented in this deal, and neither do the teachers, who are upset that the extra funds aren’t earmarked for education. In other words, the opposition is coming from those who weren’t invited to the party, those whose only real complaint is that they won’t be able to get their fingers in the pie.
The fact is that these propositions are bad for California because gambling is bad for California. Why is it that neither the legislature nor the Governor mentions the fact that before California can receive $9 billion in gambling revenue the hard-working people of California must first lose $60 billion at the slots. That’s right — $60 billion of paychecks, depleted IRA’s and social security checks are required to produce $9 billion in revenue, and we’re being told this is a good deal.
This is $60 billion that won’t be spent on braces, utility bills, mortgage payments or washing machines. This is $60 billion that won’t be used for starting new businesses, invested in equipment or placed into retirement accounts. This is $60 billion that goes down the toilet to a septic tank of gambling operators so that they are assured of having enough funds to purchase new legislators after their minions are termed out of office. I thought prostitution was only legal in Nevada. I must have been on vacation the week they decided to legalize it in Sacramento. (ed~ heh)
The fact is that every study of gambling has shown that three things occur, not sometimes, but every single time gambling comes into a community: there is an increase in crime (from burglary to embezzlement), an increase in divorce, and an increase in bankruptcy. Conservative estimates have placed the “cost” of gambling at $3-5 of social cost for every dollar of gambling revenue. Now, let’s go back and do the math. It turns out that our $9 billion “windfall” is really a $27-$45 billion plunge to death on top of the $60 billion amputation. For the first time, revenue in California will be tied directly to how much of your savings and paychecks you throw away at the casinos. The more we lose, the more politicians have to spend. If the Governor wanted to rape, pillage and plunder the hard-working people of California, he could not have devised a better plan. Who needs Attila the Hun to do it when you have a legislature at your disposal?
That Missouri Compromise? Politicians thought that it was the way by which to avert a civil war. Little did they realize that it only ensured a national bloodbath. In similar fashion, the “cure” for our financial woes will become part of the disease. That which is thought to be a way by which to avert economic devastation will only ensure our demise. Like the old medical treatment of bloodletting, by which, it was believed, the disease could be removed by removing the blood, these propositions will be the bloodletting of California. Actually those doctors had some success. They did in fact get rid of the disease — when the patient died from the cure.
Posted by
sosumi
at
10:00 AM|PERMALINK
3
comments
Labels: gambling, indian casino, Propositions 94 95 96 and 97, slot machines
Thursday, November 15, 2007
SY Valley's Journal
A few weeks ago at Capitol Weekly, this article appeared covering Nancy Crawford Hall's purchase of the local Santa Ynez paper, 'The Journal'. I am reposting it here along with the responses that have cropped up on the web regarding the original article.
Santa Ynez woman buys paper, covers tribal casino
By Malcolm Maclachlan (published Thursday, October 18, 2007)
Nancy Crawford Hall didn't like how her local newspapers were covering the nearby Chumash tribe and casino. So she did something that people have fantasized about for centuries: She bought her own newspaper.
Last October, she purchased a small monthly, the Santa Ynez Valley Journal. She turned it into a weekly and quickly began having her staff crank out stories that a spokeswoman for the Chumash has labeled "propaganda" and "conspiracy theory of the month."
"It's an interesting paper," said Frances Snyder, and tribal member and spokeswoman for the Santa Ynez Band of Chumash Indians. "Frankly, every week I dread looking at it. All of the stories are inaccurate. All of the stories are biased."
Hall claimed that hers is the only paper printing the truth about the casino--and that the community has responded. The Journal had a circulation of 6,000 when she bought it, she said, but has since grown to 22,000. She said she started looking into buying a paper after years of the other local papers refusing to print anything critical about the tribe or the casino--even in their "letters to the editor" sections.
"I can't go anywhere in town without people saying 'thank you for the paper,'" Hall said. She added, "I think we've really hit a chord. We're telling the stories no one else will tell."
Hall pens a column each week called "On the Ranch." About every third or fourth column deals with the Chumash, she said. But the paper regularly covers the group, including printing numerous letters to the editor--including one by a disgruntled tribal member, Hall said, who asked that their name be withheld.
For many in Sacramento, the first they heard about the dispute between the Chumash and local activists came in the last few weeks when Assemblyman Joe Coto, D-San Jose, successfully carried a bill to rename a section of Highway 154 as the "Chumash Highway." This angered local anti-casino activists with groups such as No More Slots and Preservation of Santa Ynez. Hall said she has never belonged to any of the local anti-casino groups.
Snyder had harsh words for the activists who oppose the renaming of Highway 154. The route had long been used by the tribe, she said, and the naming followed all legal and Caltrans rules, she said.
"Is it named the Chumash Casino Highway? No," Snyder said. Nowhere in the regulations around naming a highway, she added, does it "say you need the permission of [anti] tribal hate groups."
While the Journal has weighed in on the Highway 154 renaming, the paper has focused more squarely on what they allege are the tribes plans to expand the casino. This past spring, the Journal printed that the tribe was in negotiations for 5,000 new slot machines, along with tribes such as Pechanga and Agua Caliente, that got amended compacts in August.
The Chumash responded by saying the article was inaccurate--a point they sought to emphasize with full-page ads in several competing papers. On April 18, the Journal responded by reprinted the minutes of Chumash Tribal meeting, along with a 4,000 word story titled "Tribal Chairman Claims 'Whackos,' Tribal Government Minutes Say Otherwise." This included a quote from tribal chairman, Vincent Armenta stating: "We met with the Governor's Office but there has been no progress yet. We are asking for 5,000 machines."
Jim Marino, a local attorney who sued the Chumash twice on behalf of former casino employees but got caught in the "catch 22" of trying to sue a sovereign tribal government, said the tribe got caught with their pants down. Many tribal members themselves are angry about the way the tribe is being run by chairman Vincent Armenta, he said, which explains the regular stream of internal tribal information that has been fed to the Journal.
"They said they weren't going to expand," Marino said. "We had the blueprints of exactly where they were going to put the slot machines."
"They quit calling us liars," Hall said of the exchange.
Not quite. Snyder said the minutes were used out of context. The same quote goes on to state than new slots would be 10 years off. The Chumash were invited to talks, she said, because they are a gaming member of the Tribal Alliance of Sovereign Indian Nations, but declined to pursue expansion. Other tribal minutes would show this to be true, she said, but added that these documents are confidential.
The dispute between the tribe and locals goes back to the beginning of the tribal-gaming era. The Chumash were one of the first tribes to gain a gaming compact under then-Gov. Gray Davis.
The Chumash face something other largely rural tribes have not: an extremely well-funded opposition. The town of Santa Ynez, located 30 miles northwest of Santa Barbara, has median household income of $96,300, according to the 2000 census--a figure that precedes that advent of the casino. The statewide median income at the time was $53,600.
Some have far greater wealth than that, as well as long-term ties to the land. Hall declines to state how much she paid for the Journal, or how many horses and cows she has on the ranch her family has owned for four generations. But she owns a horse-show arena. Her great grandfather, John Vickers, was co-owner of one of the Channel Islands, Santa Rosa Island; the U.S. government bought it for $30 million in 1978.
"The other tribal opponents don't have these type of resources," Synder said. "They try really hard to look like they're not elitist. They don't represent the community."
Marino said that charges of elitism don't mean much when they're coming from a tribe that hands out $40,000 (Snyder refused to confirm this figure) in gaming money to each member every month--not to mention nearly $1 million in political donations since 2001, including $16,200 to Coto. He went on to say the tribe has used this power--and the tens of thousands they regularly spend on newspaper and television advertising--to crush any criticism in other newspapers in the area.
"It's the millions of dollars they spend plus the fear of being labeled a racist," Marino said.
Many of the comments about the tribe do have racial overtones, Synder said, especially those posted on blogs. The tribe is criticized essentially no matter what they do, she said, including when they gave $1 million to the local Cottage Hospital and $3 million to refurbish the athletic fields at Santa Ynez Valley High School.
As an entertainment venue, they do regularly advertise in the local press, she said, though not in the Journal. The real reason the opponents don't get coverage elsewhere, she said, is because their claims are inaccurate. Many writers in the area, such as Santa Barbara News-Press columnist Travis Armstrong and local blogger Rick Lee, have frequently written positive stories about the tribe.
In any case, Hall said the Journal is going to keep after the Chumash. All she ever wanted was a part in the debate, she said, and the paper has given her that in spades. She's looking at adding new staff and shining light elsewhere, as well.
"The phrase 'the power of the press' is really true," Hall said, then added, "There's a lot of sneaky stuff the county does."
Posted by
sosumi
at
9:16 AM|PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: casino, chumash, gambling, Santa Ynez, slot machines
Friday, October 26, 2007
Ripped off on the Reservation
Reading the comments at the GMA site where this story originated, you get the feeling people are missing the point. The arguement of "Pay him! Don't pay him! " seems to be irrelevant. Because of sovereign nation status - the casino cannot be sued. Tribal members can vote in US elections, can sue US citizens in US courts of law, and casinos on reservations can operate as a foreign country without tariffs or taxes.
Man Sues Casino over $1.6 million 'Jackpot"
By JIM AVILA, BETH TRIBOLET, DONNA CHOI and SCOTT MICHELS
ABC News Law & Justice Unit
Oct. 25, 2007
For about an hour last August, Gary Hoffman was a very lucky man.
Hoffman was playing the nickel slot machines at the Sandia Resort and Casino on an Indian reservation in New Mexico when he appeared to hit the jackpot: the machine said he won nearly $1.6 million.
"I became ecstatic," he said.
But the ecstasy was short-lived. Hoffman says in a lawsuit filed earlier this year that Sandia refused to pay, claiming that the machine malfunctioned. Instead, he said, they gave him about $385 and a few free meals at the casino.
"I won money, fair and square, and I've been cheated out of my winnings," Hoffman told ABC News.
The casino says it's not responsible for what it describes as a computer error and says it offered Hoffman the maximum payout of $2,500 for that particular slot machine. But, a jury may never decide who is right. Lawyers told ABC News that gamblers like Hoffman may have little legal recourse against Native American casinos, which sometimes operate beyond the reach of U.S. courts.
'I Was a Winner'
Hoffman, a retired Albuquerque city employee, was playing a "Mystical Mermaid" slot machine on the morning of Aug. 16, 2006, when he thought he hit it big.
The nickel slot said he'd won $1,597,244.10. Patrons and casino employees came to congratulate him. He even got a marriage proposal, Hoffman said. But, soon he was asked to come to an executive conference room, where he says he was told the casino refused to pay.
A casino employee "became quite intimidating with me, pointed his finger in my face and said, 'You didn't win. We're not paying you any money. Do you understand what I'm telling you? You're not getting any money,'" Hoffman said.
A technician from the slot machine manufacturer arrived at the casino within the hour and the casino cordoned off the machine.
"I was a winner and I walked out empty handed," Hoffman said.
Computer Malfunction
A technical report said the slot machine's computer malfunctioned, and incorrectly made it appear as if Hoffman won more than the machine is able to pay out. The slot machine has a disclaimer that says it pays a maximum of $2,500 and warns that malfunctions void all winnings, said Paul Bardacke, Sandia's lawyer.
Sovereign Immunity
Regardless, a jury may never get chance to hear Hoffman's case. Native American tribes, as independent nations, have their own court systems and can be sued in state courts only under limited circumstances. New Mexico law generally does not allow tribes to be sued in a state court over a contract dispute, Kleiman said.
Hoffman's lawyers say they should be able to sue the tribe over what they call big business. "They spent millions of dollars getting these customers, these gamblers, to come in and gamble money, then when someone hits it big, they say, 'Sorry, we are not going to pay you," said Hoffman's lawyer, Sam Bregman. "The jury is going to be outraged by that."
READ IT ALL
Posted by
sosumi
at
2:17 PM|PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: casino, gambling, Gaming, indian, lawsuit, reservation, Sandia, slot machines, sovereign nation
Friday, October 12, 2007
Who needs drugs? We've got slots!
Incisive study and analysis on the effects of gambling on the human mind. In PDF format from NCALG (National Coalition Against Legalized Gambling).
Machines: The 'Crack Cocaine' of gambling
Rapid Onset of Pathological Gambling in Machine Gamblers
Dr. Robert Breen and Mark Zimmerman studied the length of time it takes the average compulsive gambler to become addicted and found machines are truly the "crack cocaine" of gambling. They are also the biggest moneymakers in the gambling industry today. They addict victims about three times faster than traditional table and track gambling. (Also see Breen's slides and listen to his talk in our 2004 Conference section)
Click here to read
